Select Page

A judge in Massachusetts has scheduled a retrial for former nurse Lindsay Clancy, who is charged over the deaths of her three young children at their home in Duxbury in January 2023. The new trial will begin on 29 March 2027.

Her first trial ended in September when the jury deadlocked. The scheduling hearing took place on Monday 16 November 2026 at Plymouth Superior Court.

Key points

  • Judge William Sullivan set the retrial to begin on 29 March 2027 at Plymouth Superior Court.
  • The first trial ended in a mistrial on 4 September 2026 after an 11-1 jury split.
  • Prosecutors said the retrial would need a jury, which the defence reads as a sign they will pursue first-degree murder again.
  • The judge last week rejected a defence bid to have the charges dismissed on double jeopardy grounds.

What happened in court

Judge Sullivan fixed the date at a brief hearing on Monday. Prosecutors had argued for a later date in May, citing other cases on the court’s schedule, but the judge, who retires in June 2027, wanted March. Clancy’s lawyers had urged him to hold the trial before he retires, to avoid bringing a new judge into the case.

Assistant District Attorney Jennifer Sprague told the court that prosecutors were “ready to pick a jury trial date”. Three new counts of first-degree murder would require a jury trial, whereas second-degree murder would let her opt for a trial by judge alone.

The Plymouth County district attorney has not said publicly whether his office will pursue the same charges. Defence lawyer Kevin Reddington said the development “all but confirms they intend to retry first-degree murder”.

How the first trial ended

Judge Sullivan declared a mistrial on 4 September. Jurors could not reach a unanimous verdict on whether Clancy was criminally responsible, with eleven favouring acquittal on grounds of insanity and one disagreeing.

The defence has argued that Clancy had postpartum psychosis, a rare mental illness that can affect mothers after childbirth. Prosecutors argued she planned the killings and understood what she was doing. Clancy has never disputed that she killed the children. She has pleaded not guilty.

An insanity verdict would lead to her commitment to a state psychiatric hospital, while a guilty verdict would carry a sentence of life without parole.

Challenges to a retrial rejected

After the mistrial, the defence filed several motions to stop a second trial. Judge Sullivan rejected each of them in turn. The defence had argued that the judge should have removed the juror who favoured conviction and let deliberations continue.

In his ruling, the judge wrote that there was a “manifest necessity” for a mistrial because of the deadlock, so a retrial does not breach protection against double jeopardy. Double jeopardy is the US constitutional bar on being tried twice for the same offence.

Why it matters

The case has drawn international attention, much of it focused on the children and on postpartum mental illness. The outcome of a second trial will show how a new jury weighs the same questions about criminal responsibility.

Legal commentators have noted that the first jury’s split could be significant. CNN reported that the 11-1 division in favour of not guilty by lack of criminal responsibility suggested prosecutors could face an uphill battle. That is an assessment of the earlier vote rather than a prediction of the result.

What happens next

Lawyers are due back in court on 30 December to discuss trial logistics, security and media arrangements. Prosecutors have yet to confirm formally which charges they will bring. The case remains active and Clancy is presumed innocent unless a jury finds otherwise.

Sources