Justice Secretary Alex Norris has written to the regulator of barristers in England and Wales, asking it to stop lawyers using rape myths to defend clients. The letter follows the trial of comedian Russell Brand, who was convicted of rape and sexual assault.
Mr Norris said barristers who flout the rules could face disciplinary action, up to being barred from practice. The Bar Council, which represents barristers, has stressed the regulator’s independence from government.
Key points
- Alex Norris has written to the Bar Standards Board (BSB) calling for rules to stop barristers perpetuating rape myths in court.
- He warned that breaches could lead to disciplinary action, including being barred from practice.
- The Bar Council said defendants have a right to have evidence tested and that the BSB must remain independent of government.
- The BSB said it is already working on tougher standards for rape and serious sexual offence cases.
What the justice secretary said
In his letter to the BSB, Mr Norris said it was “unacceptable” for the profession to “perpetuate myths” about rape victims in court. The letter was first reported by The Times.
According to the Times, he also wrote that the board must send a strong signal to the profession on the harm such myths cause. He said they were as unacceptable in a courtroom as in society at large.
The BBC reported that a Ministry of Justice spokesperson said the justice secretary was “determined to make protections for victims as strong as possible”. The spokesperson added that independent judges can already give juries directions to counter rape myths. The BBC also reported that the government backed calls for a law change requiring such directions in every rape trial.
Background: the Brand trial
Rape myths are false assumptions about how victims of sexual violence are supposed to behave. In the Brand case, the defence was criticised for arguing that his accusers should not be believed because, they had not screamed, kicked out or fled.
Brand was jailed for 10 and a half years for one count of rape and three sexual assaults. He was convicted of offences against four of the six women who gave evidence against him, according to the Guardian.
At sentencing at Southwark Crown Court, Mr Justice Bennathan told Brand that women keep the right to say no, whatever they wear or drink. The judge said they could also demand justice from the criminal courts.
The Guardian reported that Brand’s barrister, Ian Winter KC, referred himself to the BSB. This followed criticism of his conduct in court and of a conversation with a Sunday Times journalist outside the court. The BSB has not said how it will respond to that referral.
Reaction from the legal profession
A Bar Council spokesperson told The Times that a defendant who denies rape has a “right to have evidence tested in court”. The spokesperson stressed that the BSB must remain independent of the government.
A BSB spokesperson said the board agrees that rape and sexual assault cases must be decided on evidence, not prejudice. The board has set up an expert reference group to advise on tougher standards for barristers in these cases. It said it would keep working urgently with the government on the issues raised.
Why it matters
Any new rules would apply to barristers acting in rape and serious sexual offence cases in England and Wales. The question of how far cross-examination and defence arguments can go is a recurring one. Conviction rates and victims’ willingness to come forward are also part of that debate.
Changes to the BSB’s handbook of conduct rules would involve consultation and regulatory approval. Mr Norris’s letter does not itself change any rules.
What happens next
The BSB has not publicly rejected the justice secretary’s call. It is expected to continue work through its expert reference group on standards for barristers in these cases. No timetable for new rules has been announced.
Sources
- BBC News – Barristers must stop using rape myths in trials, justice secretary says
- The Guardian – Barristers could be barred from practice over use of rape myths, warns justice secretary
- LBC – Lawyers must stop deploying myths about rape in wake of Brand trial, minister warns
- ITV News – Russell Brand’s message from behind bars was ‘disgusting’
- AOL (PA) – Justice Secretary calls for new rules to prohibit use of rape myths in trials


